Needed: A Culture of High Expectations

Any experienced teacher will probably agree that how a teacher acts toward a student affects how the student performs in class. If a teacher is gruff and disapproving students will be reluctant to go out on a limb and announce answers they are unsure of. If a teacher is overly laidback or permissive and doesn’t seem to mind much if assignments are of a certain quality, students will likely become lax in their assignment completion. Perhaps more commonly, if a teacher expects lively boys to be disruptive those boys will likely feel unjustly targeted by reprimands and may either shut down or act up more. Teachers might give less feedback to students who performed poorly on assessments early in the year. In short, teachers are not immune to the all-too-human tendency to judge and to categorize and adjust behavior accordingly.

To be clear, it is not a teacher’s expectations per se that affect student performance but teacher behavior toward students. While most teachers would take professional pride in being fair and impartial factors as subtle as a look, word choice, physical proximity, or time spent in engagement send constant messages to students about a teacher’s expectations. If Johnny is told harshly to sit quietly at his desk, while the teacher stands by Sally’s desk pleasantly looking over her latest writing assignment both kids are getting pretty clear messages, especially if consistent behavior is routinely displayed. Psychologist Robert Rosenthal demonstrated the power of this variation of self-fulfilling prophecy in a fascinating experiment in 1964. Rosenthal manipulated teachers’ expectations by supplying them with phony results of a misrepresented test that could purportedly identify children who were on the cusp of great intellectual growth. Rosenthal followed up after several years and found that those children who were randomly identified as supposedly poised for an intense intellectual bloom did in fact gain more in IQ. In exploring reasons for this he concluded that those children had been given more time to answer questions, more specific feedback, and more approval than their peers.

After reading several articles and studies about just this sort of cause/effect relationship between teacher expectations/behavior and student performance and then sifting the information through my own experience as a teacher it occurred to me that this is realm of the great unknown in education. We have set curricula, standardized tests, tracked student progress, and so forth, but this influential but often subtle effect of teacher-student interaction is largely hidden and unaccounted for. This is the realm in which teaching is more art than science, where experience, personality, and attitude come into play. It’s the largely hidden aspect of education that often worries parents who secretly ask themselves, “Is my kid being encouraged or stifled? Is he being challenged or slipping through the cracks? Is she made to feel comfortable and valued in class or ignored or discouraged?” And in light of those recent studies indicating that professional training and even experience are in fact not good predictors of successful teachers, one might suspect that it is the nebulous, personal factor influencing how a given teacher approaches various students that is more determinative of success in the classroom.  It is the teacher who has high expectations for all students, who is fair, encouraging, and positive when interacting with the girls, the boys, the quiet and gregarious, the more advanced and the less skilled, the troubled and the placid who will have greater success than the teacher who knowingly or unwittingly is selective in the distribution of attention and encouragement.

Some studies suggest that it is difficult to get teachers to change their expectations. Experiments with groups who were given intensive training to change their behavior yielded better results. But my questions is, could we get better by cultivating in a given school a teacher culture that specifically promotes equitable, positive, and encouraging behavior toward all students, not just the polite ones, or the apparently skilled and engaged ones, but the introverted, the rambunctious, the prickly, the withdrawn and defensive as well.

48 responses to “Needed: A Culture of High Expectations”

  1. update says:

    F*ckin?awesome things here. I’m very glad to look your article. Thanks so much and i’m having a look forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a mail?

  2. cialis india says:

    canadian cialis

    cialis price costco

  3. cheap viagra

    cheap viagra

  4. viagra 100mg says:

    viagra generic

    cheap viagra

  5. erection pills online

    pills for erection

  6. erectile dysfunction pills

    best erection pills

  7. buy ed pills online

    erectile dysfunction medication

  8. order cialis says:

    order cialis

    order cialis

  9. canadian online pharmacy

    canadian online pharmacy

  10. rx pharmacy

    walmart pharmacy

  11. Buy cialis says:

    Buy cialis

    Buy cheap cialis

  12. Viagra or cialis

    Real cialis online

  13. vardenafil online

    levitra online

  14. levitra coupon

    vardenafil 10 mg

  15. pala casino online

    real money casino games

  16. online casino real money no deposit

    online casino real money paypal

  17. generic sildenafil

    viagra alternative

  18. play online casino real money

    online casino games

  19. casino online slots

    play online casino real money

  20. buy cialis says:

    buy tadalafil 20mg price

    cialis generic name

  21. loans online

    cash loans

  22. pay day loans

    personal loan

  23. cash loan

    cash advance online

  24. viagra for sale

    viagra for sale

  25. cialis buy

    new cialis

  26. 5 mg cialis

    cialis to buy

  27. cialis 20 says:

    generic for cialis

    cialis generic

  28. cialis 20 says:

    generic cialis

    cialis buy

  29. cialis 5 mg

    cialis generic

  30. online casino usa

    free casino games

  31. slot machine

    gambling games

  32. online casino usa real money

    best online casino usa

  33. online casino gambling

    free slots online

  34. generic for viagra

    viagra sildenafil

  35. cheap viagra says:

    viagra without a doctor prescription

    purchase viagra

  36. generic viagra

    viagra reviews

  37. generic cialis

    generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg from india

  38. tadalafil cialis

    tadalafil cialis

  39. cialis buy online

    buy cialis online reddit

  40. cialis price says:

    buy cialis online

    cialis generic

  41. best online casino for money

    slots online

  42. Price check 50mg viagra

    Viagra 100mg england

  43. Buy real viagra online without prescription

    Buy pfizer viagra online

  44. Buy viagra says:

    How to get viagra

    Viagra overnight

  45. Cialis or viagra

    Female viagra

  46. Us pharmacy viagra

    Viagra overnight

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Calendar

September 2012
M T W T F S S
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930